Nancy's Pizza Chicago West Loop

Cha'Vaa Barrett 4 weeks ago

I was visiting Chicago and saw so many reviews about Nancy's Pizza so naturally I wanted to try it. I DoorDashed a small pizza from Nancy's. After eating one slice I noticed there was bug( looked like a mosquito) on my pizza. The pizza was good but the bug kind of ruined it for me. I would give them another try because that is a one off mistake

Tiffany Ente 2 months ago

This restaurant is outstanding! The ambiance was on point - chill but modern for a pizza spot. The service was great, but the food is definitely the highlight. The mixed salad was fresh and light, the wet lemon pepper wings were juicy and seasoned to perfection, and the deep dish pizza was the best I’ve ever had. The crust was light, it wasn’t overly saucy, and the cheese was delicious! BEST DEEP DISH!!

Philip Smith 4 months ago

This review is for the location on Washington Ave. at Carpenter St. We ordered two small pizzas: A thin crust with sausage, and a “rustic” style with black olives. I really enjoyed the thin crust, it had a nice crunch with more flavor than some “cracker crust” pizzas. The sausage had just the right amount of fennel, and the sauce was good. The rustic style was equally good; the crust has more volume but is still not thick, and any toppings plus sprinkled Parmesan are baked on top. As a starter, we split the Caesar salad. It was very good but note to vegetarians — ask for it without the bacon bits. We haven’t been to any of the Nancy’s locations. We would come back to this one just because we know how good it was! Service was friendly and fast. We found parking on Carpenter right in front of the entrance, and paid with Park Chicago app.

Jason Johnson 6 months ago

Amazing service. Drove about 3 hours out of my way to try their stuffed pizzas after seeing them online and was blown away. Our server let us know what we were getting into so we knew what to order. We ordered a large stuffed pizza with pepperoni and some mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks were served.with some sort of pesto-based sauce along with the.marinara, making it a refreshing take on an appetizer I have had multiple times before. The stuffed pizza was amazing. The sauce is great and there's plenty of it. Definitely worth the drive to get here. We will be ordering some of the frozen pizzas in the future.

Chris Horntvedt 6 months ago

Nancy’s pizza was recommended to me by two coworkers and I’m so happy we tried it out. The stuffed pizza (deep dish) was delicious and worth the visit on its own. Their tavern style, thin crust pizza was also great. We ordered the cheese stuffed pizza and the Rocco’s Party (Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper). The sausage was flavorful and the crust was crispy. I’d advise on making a reservation as it can get busy on nights and weekends. They also offer a take out option for anyone not wanting to dine in.